Allreaders.com

Hidden Histories of Science Book Review Summary

Detailed Plot Synopsis of Hidden Histories of Science

This is a collection of five essays in the history of the biological sciences, two of which are particularly good and either one alone is worth the value of the book. Possibly the best is Daniel J. Kevles; 'Pursuing the unpopular: a history of courage, viruses, and cancer'. I read this with delight as it is a model of concise and precise scientific exposition. It carefully traces progress from around 1900 to the time of the early AIDS crisis for the evidence that viruses may be a cause of cancer, covering the difficulties replicating the early results, and the mixed motives that alternately constrained and allowed progress. The politics of the science itself and the possible social impact of publishing partial results is clearly demonstrated, along with the more obvious interplay of collecting mere facts and finding best fit within the competing theoretical frameworks. This research is a great success for science, but it will not please the animal rights camp as it is also a clear and undeniable example of the essential utility of animal models in medical research.

The second excellent contribution is by Dr. Oliver Sacks; 'Scotoma: forgetting and neglect in science'. This sets the intellectual juices running and inspired me to look some of the references up. He considers the scientific process as seen in neurology and psychophysiology, making an interesting contrast to Kuhn's physical sciences approach in his famous study. He illustrates with his personal experiences with the 'phantom limb' phenomenon (significant dissolution of body image), and his research into the early literature of migraine, muscular dystrophy, chaos theory, Tourette's syndrome, colour-blindness and visual perception in general. In his concluding section he presents a basic taxonomy of errors in the process of scientific thinking, in particular his analysis of 'scotoma', not merely the misunderstanding and forgetting of early ground-breaking scientific discoveries, but their actual deletion from the active mind due to inadequate theoretical framework to contain them. If I may borrow from computerese, he builds a convincing multi-threaded argument, though some of the processes terminate normally and some do not.

Dr. Jonathan Miller presents a prolix but entertaining overview the history of psychology from the perspective of the concept of Mind, covering hypnosis, 'the long drought of Behaviourism' (well said that man), Freud, and the re-emergence of the mind in cognitive psychology with the beginnings of artificial intelligence and the influence of Chomsky's 'deep syntax' linguistic theory.

Stephen Jay Gould and R.C. Lewontin write on evolution, but to relatively little avail, alas.
This report prepared by Michael JR Jose








Please enter the number 42 plus two in the right box.
    

Chapter Analysis of Hidden Histories of Science

Click on a plot link to find similar books!

Kind Of History

Time of history:    -   Early 1900's    -   20th century    -   19th century Nationality?    -   American--General History of a science?    -   Yes Kind of science    -   Psychiatry

Subjects of this Historical Account

Ethnicity (if plays a major part)    -   European/White Is the portrayal sympathetic?    -   Sympathetic From a certain profession/group?    -   bureaucracy Intelligence of subject of history:    -   Smart

Setting

United States    -   Yes The US:    -   Northeast Europe    -   Yes European country:    -   Germany    -   England/UK    -   France Big City?    -   Yes City:    -   New York    -   London If applicable, liberal/conservative?    -   Historian is very moderate

Writing Style

How much gore?    -   2 () How fast-paced is the book?    -   1 () Accounts of torture and death?    -   generic/vague references to death/punishment Book makes you feel...    -   encouraged How much focus on stories of individuals?    -   Focuses mostly on history of key players How much romance?    -   1 () Minor characters feature lots of:    -   doctors Pictures/Illustrations?    -   A significant amount Length of book    -   150-200 pages How much emphasis on small details?    -   8 ()

Books with storylines, themes & endings like Hidden Histories of Science

Robert B. Silvers Books Note: the views expressed here are only those of the reviewer(s).
2 Ways to Search!
Or




Feedback


Our Chief Librarian