Allreaders.com

David Eddings Message Board


morning glory posts on 4/27/2005 5:36:38 PM wow...first & foremost, if ever the belgariad & the mallorean series are made into film, i'd much appreciated it if they'd stick straight to the book....knowing hollywood....i can't imagine alec baldwin as zakath?? my thoughts are more on clive owen as zakath & ian mckellan as belgarath, for polgara....hmmm...i kinda agree with the choice of cat zeta-jones coz she's got the polgara-esque likeness about her....i like beldin's character & i think john rhys-davies would make an excellent beldin since he's got tat wickedly sarcastic charisma abt him... for silk....it would be tough...got to find a rodent-faced guy....adrien brody???
thora posts on 4/16/2005 7:07:58 PM why would you, as real fans of eddings,like to see our world destroyed by cgi?why do you want to see one of the best stories ever told corrupted by hollywood?tolkien's lord of the rings is a fantastic read.it's been made into a spoonfeed for the masses because of hollywood's need to bring in ratings.not many will know the joys of reading tolkien's lord of the rings and the hobbit,why would they when it's on dvd?we should protect the joy of reading eddings.if we all object, then maybe we can keep the joys of reading a book for the future generations.don't let it be made into a hollywood sham.that goes for all books,let's keep the delight in reading alive.we're too wrapped up in tv and cinema.let's get back to the libraries of the world.it can open the door to many different worlds.embrace them.
isla posts on 4/16/2005 6:05:56 PM i love eddings.i immerse myself in each new world completely.i love the fact that you can identify with each different character in your own way.he makes them human,which is rare in a fantasy writer.i've read his books numerous times and i love that,even though yov've read it 50 times, you'll still find new little details each time you read it.it's the ultimate read.what a wonderful world he's created for us.



Lee posts on 4/6/2005 7:11:35 PM While we all wait for the movie(s), there are great audio editions of the Belgariad and Mallorean available from Books in Motion. They have a website. The reader is really good. All the characters sounded like I imagined them to be. I listened to the CD version, but they have them in cassette and CD both.
wiggles posts on 3/30/2005 10:37:35 AM hey i'm only 15 and first read the belgariad when i was 7, thought it was brilliant , too bad the mallorean was a bit of a let down. i'm not sure if i want to see it on film im not sure if its because i love having this own little world that i can just escape too, i hope no one thinks that i'm too sad but i get a great feeling readin these books over and over. lol! i've read the belgariad more than 50 times over, sad or what? great set of books though, eh? but, if it was to be on film, i would have christopher lambert as the vioce of prophecy, i just think he has that dry quality you know? i'd have sean connery (as someone said) as belgarath and possibly zeta jones as polgara. it would have to be some one truly lovable for silk though, isnt he great.
Jenny posts on 3/29/2005 2:18:21 PM I too would like to see The Belgariad and The Mallorean immortalised on film. I always see Sean Connery as Belgarath. If she was a little younger Jane Seymour as Polgara. Brian Blessed as Barak and as Silk...mmm always struggle with that one! Suggestions anyone? Garion I see as my son Vincent who is 15 and has that dopey look down pat!! What does everyone else think? Jenny.
Beldarius posts on 3/29/2005 11:29:49 AM Yeah, maybe a good idea, but I can't seem to think of a good actor for Martel. I mean, hair color and eye-color can be changed, but who's going to be as derisive and relaxed as Martel when saying: 'Old boy' ? And Ulath... is there an actor big enough ? I thought Clive Owen could be Sparhawk. And just Torak's Tim Roth and Zakath's Alec Baldwin. Silk's Stephen Baldwin. And Tynian's Sean Bean. Of course, Voice of Prophecy... James Earl Jones. Could you think anyone better ?
Enigma posts on 3/4/2005 12:43:10 PM Addicted Belgariad & Mallorean fan desperately wants tv series or movie based on the novels. Why should the likes of Tolkien & his hobbits or JK Rowlings Harry Potter get all the mad reviews? I think The Belgariad & The Mallorean series would make for fantastic viewing & entertainment if it is done well. I just wish I was that way inclined & gifted in cinematics, I would undertake the project myself. Doesn't anybody else wish to see this thing televised or made a movie epic like Star Wars or Ewok Adventure or The Lord of The Rings?
fred posts on 2/23/2005 7:21:18 PM if they ever did make a movie about the elenium the special efects budget would be huge not to mention all of the characters that have 5-6 lines in the books also getting someone big enough to play miriti although it would be so cool if they ever did
Phedre posts on 2/22/2005 11:59:39 PM if they did make a movie, then you couldn't have really well known actores play the parts, coz they wouldn't do it very well. at my school, we had this thing called Night of the Notables. and i did david eddings. it was fab to find out stuff on him. i also wrote to him and he wrote back and it was so exiting to get his letter, hes a realy nice person. my favourite books are the belgariad and the Mallorean!!! they were the some of the best books iv read!!
Click Here for Messages:    1 - 10   11 - 20   21 - 30   31 - 40   41 - 50   51 - 60   61 - 70  
Click here to post a message to this forum




Note: the views expressed here are only those of the posters.
2 Ways to Search!
Or





Our Chief Librarian