Jonathan Stroud Message Board
bitches posts on 4/12/2007 6:40:39 PM
this book is so bad it makes me want to kill your mom.
Empress Ayla posts on 3/21/2007 9:28:29 AM
Elheret has basically been banned from coming here btw, i cant tell you any more than that, and i havnt been here since like december
..... posts on 3/2/2007 10:06:07 PM
I miss Kitty, Elheret, everyone else.
Come back !
Bart Roxs! posts on 2/22/2007 8:29:32 PM
How could any of you guys hate the ending? I LOVED IT! It was like the best ending ever, so surprising and cool. I DO NOT WANT THERE TO BE A MOVIE! IT WOULD SO RUIN IT! About the ending, I think the part about Ptolmy is sad but with Nat dying? I DONT CARE!
Nat posts on 1/28/2007 12:16:47 AM
Sorry folks, but this board is dead.I can still see my post from October. Hurry up Mr. Shroud, keep this board alive!
Empress Ayla posts on 12/15/2006 12:49:08 PM
Man this has got to be the 5th time Ive said this! JS said he may write a sequel if he got bored and they are making a film. The film rights sold to mirimax three years ago and is coming out in a few years. They're also making a cartoon version in german with english subtitles called des amulets.The ending rocked!! even though i really didnt want nathaniel to die. Look at it in the veiw of the author - how would you have ended it, and make it a special one, not just with lovestruck nathaniel and kitty getting together, and barti getting away to the other world? o yes and i forgot to say he's rumored to have been writting a book called the other place - bad sadly barty's said to not be in it.
Kenta Yoshiyori posts on 11/30/2006 8:46:33 PM
this books is selling in Japan. Sorry I am new to write English
Tchue posts on 11/23/2006 10:25:13 PM
I would also be very interested in some new books relating to the Bartimaeus trilogy. Perhaps Kitty summons Bartimaeus in order to see if he truly died or not (or possibly on accident - while summoning something else, she says Bartimaeus' name) Also, how about books detailing the adventures of Bartimaeus and Nathaniel between Book 1 and Book 3 besides Book 2. He mentions the Amulet and the Oyster, as well as a few others. I would definitely read those stories, would you?
Kitty posts on 11/18/2006 10:39:37 PM
Does of you that are not English, what are you? -Did the movie for the trilgoy come out already?-I did cry when nat died. i cried a lot. I do hope jonathan stroud writes a sequel to the trilogy because the ending was unfathomable. But, I have heard that the only reason why he would continue the trilogy was if he was bored and didn't know how to start a new story. Well, I have to go you guys. Bye!
Attanai posts on 11/16/2006 8:11:09 AM
Hi...hm so I agree the conclusion could be better, but also worse...:) I was really sad when Nat dead I must confess I cried a little, but it was generous death... I think so...
I can´t imagine the next novels os Barti - what would they were about? i don´t know but it´d be great...:)
And do you think Nat and Kitty were - just a little - in love? it was looking so, and that´s one of the reason why I didn´t enjoy the conclusion... unhappy relationship yeah...
And about the movie - usually I don´t like watching movie versions of my favourite books ´cause it´s completely different then my own vision. For example such as harry potter. after Bartimaeus it´s my most favourite book set - i love it and although yes, i did like the movie versions, some of characters were quite strange and... hm, it´s maddening ´cause when I´m reading HP, my presonal ( previos ) visions are mixed with movie visions and it´s not that! °)
Yees maybe you think I´m crazy but it´s my opinion :-) So a movie version of Barti... no, it´s nothing for me :) I prefer books..
Uuuf so yes i´m near the end of my devious speculation, ... I ‘ d like to apologize my non-acquaintances of English language, I´m not english... hi, xxx
Click Here for Messages:
1 - 10
11 - 20
21 - 30
31 - 40
41 - 50
51 - 60
61 - 70
Note: the views expressed here are only those of the posters.