A competition is held in Dodge City on July 4, 1876 to test marksmanship, with the prize being a rare “one in a thousand” Winchester rifle. Stripped of their weapons by Sheriff Wyatt Earp (Geer), two participants enter with a lot of animosity toward one another: Lin McAdam (Stewart) and Dutch Henry Brown (McNally). Brown has killed the man who taught both to shoot so well and McAdam, with High Spade Wilson (Mitchell), is out to catch Brown and bring him to justice after trailing him for a long time. A saloon girl named Lola (Winters) is put on a coach to leave town for the duration of the festivities. McAdam wins the contest and the gun but he is jumped and robbed by Brown and his sidekicks.
Click here to see the rest of this review
The good guys track Brown and his men to a saloon but miss them by a couple hours. It was at the saloon that Brown gambled away the coveted rifle to an Indian trader in exchange for guns and ammo that they had been forced to leave behind in Dodge City. The rifle changes hands again when Young Bull (Hudson) takes the rifle that was not for sale from the trader, who is killed in the process. Young Bull has pinned down a cavalry division in a valley. Lola and her scared boyfriend Steve Miller (Drake) ride into the camp with Young Bull and warriors in pursuit. A short time later, McAdam and Wilson ride in under the same conditions. The Indians led by Young Bull are turned back after Young Bull is killed. The good guys, former rebel soldiers during the Civil War, continue in their pursuit of Brown, not realizing the rifle they seek is laying on the ground where Young Bull fell in battle.
Miller takes the gun and Lola to their ranch house. There the pair are waylaid by outlaw Waco Johnny Dean (Duryea) and Miller is shot and killed by Dean in a petty squabble. The criminals flee the now blazing house and Dean takes the Winchester and Lola to a hideout where Brown and his men are holed up. Brown spots his gun and demands it back. The crooks are planning a big robbery of the bank in Tuscosa. McAdam and Wilson meet up with Lola for the third time, as she plays piano in a bar in town. McAdam roughs up Dean trying to find Brown and then guns Dean down. Brown shoots Lola in the arm hoping to slow down McAdam from chasing him. Wilson tells Lola that McAdam and Brown are brothers and Brown shot and killed their father. The two sharp shooting brothers have a final fateful confrontation.
The review of this Movie prepared by David Fletcher