Zana Muhsen Message Board
Talia posts on 9/1/2008 12:55:00 PM
Great to know Nadia is back. If she is safely home then theres really no reason to continue this fight about publicity.
Cal posts on 9/1/2008 12:42:24 PM
Hi, this is a very difficult subject to resolve. If Nadia/Zana or family comment on their current situation(s) it would become a worldwide issue. The books went out to many countries and no-one, I presume, other than those involved or close friends, really knows Nadia's or Zana's true feelings on what has happened over the years. I don't have children but I can imagine that Nadia @ the time would feel that she could never leave her children there without her. However, on the other hand, I would imagine that Zana would have felt the same way about leaving her son, however, it would have been 'easier' knowing that Nadia was in the Yemen, leaving Zana to come back to the UK to try to get help to get them back. Zana took on an enormous battle to get her sister/family back but @ the same time Nadia would have had to get used to the situation to simply survive and bring up her children. Maybe she has adapted to the Yemen way, maybe not. But @ the end of the day only Nadia can say. We should wish them all the very best as each one of them has had to fight their own private battles.
angel posts on 8/25/2008 4:32:06 AM
Thank's for giving us this information.
Nas posts on 8/24/2008 7:28:11 PM
Can I just say something to all of you lot who are interested in Nadia’s story and who are keen to know what has happened to her. Well Nadia is currently living in the UK with her husband and her children; she has been living in the UK for couple of years now. Nadia has visited Yemen several times for holiday and she wants to go back Yemen to carry on living there.
Nadia’s mum and her sister Zana has wrote books and they have been involved with the other media. They have done this for one reason which is MONEY because now Nadia live in the UK and they don’t even call her to say how she’s doing??... They have denigrated Nadia world wide because she said it before and she said it again that she always loved her husband and she always loved living in Yemen.
Now you going to start asking questions how do I know all of this?? Well I know Nadia Muhsen very well and she is ashamed with what her mum and sister done to her because they have exaggerated with lies so much to make people feel sympathy for them.
Kelly posts on 8/22/2008 4:54:20 PM
yeah this story is sad! an yeah i have a heart, dont comment on me when u dont even know me! y am i strange? because i dont think like u? Not everything in life is happy! God didnt make us 2 lead "Happy" lives 24/7! things happen 4 a reason! maybe its happened to make ppl aware of what does go on in the world! but u no wha its happened. ppl were told 2 stay away as publicity was making it worse, and what do they do????? they make even more publicity!!!!! do u honestly think if Nadia could turn back time she wudnt go??? It sounds to me that her kids r her life an she wudnt change them 4 the world! maybe her kids make her happy? maybe she has friends? maybe she actually loves her husband now? maybe she thinks of yemen as her home? maybe jus maybe she is actually happy!!!and this is my point! ppl always c the glass half empty!if her life is really as bad as u all make out, y is she still alive??? y didnt she kill herself???y cant u ppl hope that her version of events r happier better ones? because i find that really "Strnge"! And by the way she wasnt kidnapped, she went of her own accord when offered 2 go, and as she states in 1 of her interviews she knew y she was going and so did her mum! and as she also states in alot of her interviews, she is a Muslim, so maybe, just maybe she wud like to lead a life practising Islam in a country were she can properly!
Anonymous posts on 8/22/2008 5:07:34 AM
"Giving your view" "making the best of a bad situation" "why can no one else see it" - you are a strange person!!! No-one should have to make the best of a bad situation. This girl was kidnapped by her father and left with strangers/abusers - 5, 10, 20 years should not make a difference - a crime has been committed. If Nazi war criminals can be prosecuted many years after the event and murders with advances in DNA can be (and rightly so) then these men who committed this act of merciless should be tried and sentenced and maybe then they could make the best of their bad situation!!! see how they like it!!!! you must have no heart as I know in my heart I would never be willing to live that way and be happy about it!!! I know many people will see my point of view.
Kelly posts on 8/21/2008 6:04:37 PM
i think u ppl got me wrong! what zana wrote could well be true, but have we not all been taught 2 listen 2 both sides of the story? there is always 2 sides!as for her mother, i know 4 fact that if that was my mother there would be no way she wud let me go if she had already lost 2 kids! she must of known!Nadia says that her mother knew, and nadia says that she loves yemen and that she is happy in yemen and with her family, so y does evey1 always believe the saddest version? (zana version) its seems 2 me that ppl only believe what they want to believe,they hear what they want 2 hear.Zana herself was told by Nadia to stop with all the press because it was causing her trouble at home, but did she? NO! she done what she wanted to do!of cause it would cause trouble at home if u and ur family were in the press every day world wide, if that was my husband i dont think he wud be to happy,for my family to be acting this way, disgracing his family name! Yes it is wrong to marry children, yes it is wrong to take ur child away from her home and leave her thier, and yes it is wrong for alot of the things that goes on, but have u ever thought that maybe Nadia is making the best of a bad situation? and to answer both questions, yes i read all books, i read yemen times, observer and local yemen and british papers and seen photo's from the late 90's wer i think she looks great 4 a woman who had lived in a village 4 around 20 years!with not very goood amenities. plz think about what i am saying before u right back to me,i am not critisizing i am giving my view and wondering y no 1 else can c it
angel posts on 8/21/2008 4:23:45 AM
Kelly,I think you should read the books again.Maybe you didn't understand it.Yes Miriam lost 2 children more and maybe she could have known what will happen with Nadia and Zana.But all of them had and maybe have still a terrible life there in Jemen,so don't say,Nadia has a nice life what she can enjoy.Crazy to think that someone could be happy under this conditions.And grown up in a much better life than they had all this years in Jemen.
anonymous posts on 8/21/2008 2:29:16 AM
Kelly, Miriam had to going through a big manipulation 1980. how can you judge Zana and Miriam so hard...have you read all their books?! The lows have maybe change here in west, but don,t be so naiv..Zana is a person who no that her and Nadias lives is in Gods hand, not in hers!
Kelly posts on 8/20/2008 6:05:45 PM
Listen i no u all care about Nadia, but does any1 ever think about the other side of the story? Miriam already lost 2 kids (Ahmed & Laila) so why did she let Zana & Nadia go? She must of known what was going on! and dont u all realise that Zana's version of the story caused Nadia all this pain an heartache and trouble! That might be the case in Zana's eyes but maybe Nadia really is happy? y does every1 paint such a morbid picture about this girls life? She is a muslim and lives by her beliefs!can no1 give her credit 4 doing wha she feels is right by her? U all give her sympathy, if she was so unhappy she wud of gone!u all listen 2 one side of a story and beleive it???? I hope she has had a great life in Yemen and since 1980's laws have changed so much! if she really wanted 2 leave i believe she wud of! Zana wants to b ashamed of herself causing all this heartache and trouble, what wil be wil be our lives are in gods hands not Zana Muhsens!
Click Here for Messages:
1 - 10
11 - 20
21 - 30
31 - 40
41 - 50
51 - 60
61 - 70
71 - 80
81 - 90
91 - 100
101 - 110
111 - 120
121 - 130
131 - 140
141 - 150
151 - 160
161 - 170
171 - 180
181 - 190
191 - 200
Note: the views expressed here are only those of the posters.